Key takeaways

Freelance platforms like Upwork and Fiverr are built for projects. Upwork requires clients to keep work and payments on Upwork for two years, or pay a conversion fee of 13.5 percent of estimated yearly earnings.

Hiring directly from a job board like Indeed or LinkedIn means you do the finding, screening, and payroll yourself.

A staffing agency finds and screens candidates for you, and you interview a shortlist. A staffing partner stays involved after the start date.

Who employs the person is a real question. The IRS looks at who controls how the work is done, not the label on the contract.

The real burden of any path is the hours you spend screening, managing, and starting over when a hire leaves.

Each option wins somewhere: freelance for short projects, direct hire when you know the role, and a staffing partner when the hire has to last.

For a full-time role I plan to keep, I would use a staffing partner unless I have the time and skill to screen candidates myself. If I do, I would hire directly from a job board. I would keep freelance platforms like Upwork and Fiverr for short projects with a clear scope. The right pick comes down to how much screening, payroll, and replacement risk you want to own.

For years at a digital agency, I hired directly and ran every step myself. That taught me what each step costs in hours. Here’s how the three paths compare, and the questions I would ask before you pick one.

What Is the Difference Between a Staffing Agency, Direct Hire, and a Freelance Platform?

All three options can fill a role, sure. But they differ in who does the work of finding, screening, and keeping the person.

A staffing agency finds and screens candidates for you. Some agencies charge a one-time placement fee and step away once the person starts. A staffing partner charges a recurring fee and stays involved after the start date. You can see how our process works as one example of the partner model.

Direct hire means you find, screen, and employ the person yourself, usually through a job board like Indeed or LinkedIn. Staffing firms also use "direct hire" for a placement where they find the person and you employ them. In this article, those placements go under the staffing agency column.

A freelance platform is a marketplace where self-employed people bid on work. You pick from their proposals and profiles, and the platform processes the payments.

Here is how the three compare side by side.

FactorStaffing agencyDirect hire (job board)Freelance platform
What you payA placement fee, often 20% of first-year pay (SIA, 2022), or a monthly fee. More Staffing: $1,000 a month per full-time hire, plus their pay and a $1,000 one-time fee.Job ads and your time. OnlineJobs.ph: $69 or $99 a month.The freelancer's rate plus platform fees. Upwork: about 5% on Basic, plus a contract fee.
Who finds candidatesThe agency's recruitersYou, through ads and referralsYou, from proposals and profiles
Who screensThe agency, then you interview a shortlistYouYou, with reviews from past gigs
Who is the employerPlacement: you. Staffing partner: depends on the structure, so askYou, or an employer of recordNo one. The freelancer is self-employed
Who handles payPlacement: you. Partner: often coordinated by the partnerYouThe platform processes payments
What happens if it failsReplacement terms vary. More Staffing: 1 free replacement over the first 12 monthsYou start the search againYou post again
Best forA full-time role that must last, when you lack the time or skill to screenA role you know well, with time and a hiring processShort projects with a clear scope

How Much Does Each Option Really Cost?

Start with the sticker price. Then look at the hours, because that is where most of the cost hides.

An agency placement often costs 20 percent of first-year pay. That figure comes from a 2022 survey of staffing firms by Staffing Industry Analysts. Our guide on how much do staffing agencies charge covers the other fee models in more depth.

A job board costs ad spend plus your hours. OnlineJobs.ph pricing is $69 a month for Pro or $99 a month for Premium, according to its pricing page.

On Upwork, you pay the freelancer's rate plus a client marketplace fee. Its pricing page lists about 5 percent on the Basic plan, plus a one-time contract fee of $0.99 to $14.99 per contract. If you want to hire that person outside the platform within two years, Upwork's conversion fee is 13.5 percent of their estimated yearly earnings.

We charge "$1,000 a month per full-time hire, plus their pay and a $1,000 one-time fee." You can see the full breakdown on our pricing page.

Now comes the real cost. Someone has to screen, interview, onboard, and manage the hire, and start over if it fails. SHRM's 2025 benchmarking survey puts the average cost per hire for non-executive roles at $5,475. That’s the money only. It does not account for your time.

My own estimate: a direct hire for a role like a designer or coordinator takes 16 to 20 of my own hours, from the job post to day one, if I keep my standards high.

Are Staffing Agencies Worth It?

Sometimes yes, sometimes no. It really depends on the role and on what you already have in place.

An agency is worth it when the role is full time and has to last. It is worth it when you lack the hours or the skill to vet that kind of role. It is also worth it when you want help with payroll and compliance. Those are the real benefits of using a staffing agency.

It is not worth it for project work. It is also hard to justify when you already have a recruiter and know the role well.

If you do use one, check it before you sign. When I judge whether an agency is worth the fee, my answer is short: Track record. I look for reviews and case studies.

Then I check three more things:

  • Is the person's pay shown apart from the agency's fee?
  • What does the agency do after the start date?
  • What are the replacement terms if the hire leaves?

Our list of red flags in an offshore staffing agency covers the warning signs to watch for.

When Does Hiring Directly From a Job Board Make Sense?

Hiring directly makes sense when you know the role well. You can write the job post, judge the answers, and spot a weak work sample. You also need the hours, and a way to handle pay and compliance yourself or through an employer of record.

In the agency vs direct hire choice, this is the path with the lowest fees. You post on Indeed or LinkedIn, run structured interviews, and give a short work sample. You hold the whole process, so you also hold every result.

OnlineJobs.ph works the same way. It is a job board, not a staffing service. Hiring there is a direct hire in the Philippines, and you do the screening.

The hidden cost is time. SHRM's 2025 data puts the median time to fill a nonexecutive role at about a month and a half, from job requisition to offer acceptance. My own 16 to 20 hours fall somewhere inside that window, on top of my regular work.

If you are weighing a hire abroad against a hire at home, our page on offshore vs. local hiring lays out that choice.

What Is the Difference Between Contract to Hire and Direct Hire?

Contract to hire means the person works on a contract for a trial period before you make a permanent offer. Direct hire means a permanent hire from day one. Pick contract to hire vs direct hire based on how sure you are about the role.

Can You Hire a Full-Time Employee on Upwork, Fiverr, or OnlineJobs.ph?

The agency vs freelancer question comes down to what you need: a project or a person who stays.

You can find ongoing contract help on Upwork, but full time is not what it is built for. Its terms require you to keep work and payments on Upwork for the first two years. To move someone off sooner, you pay the conversion fee. Fiverr is built for gigs and small tasks. Neither Upwork nor Fiverr is designed for a full-time hire.

Can I Hire a Full-Time Employee on Upwork?

You can, but Upwork is not built for a full-time hire, either. Its terms require you to keep work and payments on the platform for two years as well, or pay a conversion fee of 13.5 percent of the freelancer's estimated yearly earnings.

Gregg Carey, CEO of More Staffing, calls Upwork "the Tinder of offshore staffing." His point is that the person can keep taking other offers while they work for you. He also says a marketplace works well for a short-term project, and the trouble starts when you try to build a team on it.

Buyers who hired on Upwork themselves report a common pattern: the search took a lot of work, and some later found that the freelancer had shared their login details with other people.

Is OnlineJobs.ph Legit for Hiring in the Philippines?

Yes. OnlineJobs.ph is a real job board based in Utah, with Pro at $69 a month and Premium at $99 a month. You do the screening and you pay the person yourself. If you go this way, read our guide to hiring remote workers in the Philippines first.

I have not hired from these platforms myself. But at my old agency, I saw full-time work handed to freelancers. There was a general lack of ownership and accountability. Many were juggling different jobs, different clients, different tasks at the same time, without telling us.

Who Screens the Candidates, and Who Is the Employer?

On a freelance platform, you screen, with reviews from past gigs to help. On a direct hire, you screen. With an agency, the agency screens and you interview a shortlist.

Good screening looks the same on every path: a structured interview, a work sample, and reference checks. Our post on pre-vetting in staffing explains why each step is important.

With a staffing partner, I draw a clear line. I will set:

  • What does a successful hire look like?
  • What kind of value do they create for the company?
  • What kind of time do they save for me?
  • What kind of problems are they going to solve?
  • What kind of character will they have?

I basically set the vision, and I determine what success looks like, and then the rest can be handled by the staffing partner. I still do the final interview. Gregg says the same thing: the partner brings the talent, but you still need rigor in your own interview.

Then there is the employer question. A freelancer is self-employed. On a direct hire, the employer is you or an employer of record. On an agency placement, it is you. With a staffing partner, it depends on the structure, so ask.

One more thing: the label on the contract does not settle it. According to the IRS, a remote worker can be your employee under U.S. tax rules if you can control what is done and how it is done. Our guide to independent contractor vs employee covers the freelancer vs employee question in more detail.

What Happens If the Hire Does Not Work Out?

On a freelance platform, you post again. On a direct hire, you start the search again and absorb the cost. With an agency, terms vary, so read carefully before you sign. Ours is "1 free replacement over the first 12 months."

A bad hire costs more than a fee. Gallup estimated in 2019 that replacing one employee can cost one-half to two times that person's yearly salary.

I learned this the hard way. One candidate did well in interviews. She was well-spoken and seemed smart. Once she started, she had many demands and was slow to respond. Her mother set her schedule, including which meetings she could attend. We tried to coach her, but it did not work, and we let her go a week in. In the end, weirdly, she felt she had been treated unfairly.

By my own count, that hire took not less than 48 hours of my time, from the job post through interviews, onboarding, coaching, and her exit.

What I'd Pick for a Full-Time Role, and Why

I would ask three questions before I pick a path.

  1. Will this role still exist in two years?
  2. Do I have the hours and skill to screen for it?
  3. Do I want to own pay, compliance, and replacement?

If the role will not last, I would use a freelance platform and keep the scope clear. If it will last and I have the hours and skill to screen, I would hire directly from a job board. If it will last and I do not want to own screening, pay, and replacement, I would use a staffing partner.

If a peer at a $50M company asked me which path to use for their next full-time hire, I would tell them that if they're hiring offshore, they should hire an agency based on the simple fact of: you can hold them accountable for the entire process and results. They're paying for "insurance," for things not to be messed up. An agency will have the expertise, experience, networks, tools, people already in place to deliver the best results.

That bad hire taught me not to rush. Today I would take more time to choose and vet the person. I would add more rounds of interviews, and I would ask harder questions that reveal character. If I want integrity, I do not ask, "Do you have integrity?" I ask for a story that shows it.

We find proven Filipino professionals, and More Staffing hires go through the same kind of screening before you meet them. See the roles we fill.

Ready to Hire Someone For the Long Run?

If your next hire is full time and has to last, start with the three questions above. If your answers point to a partner, tell us about the role on a short call. We will walk you through how we screen and what you would pay.

Start Hiring

Read more

Read article
Smiling remote professional working on a laptop beside a map of the Philippines, with checklist, chat, and growth icons
Managing Remote Teams

Offshore Staff Retention: How to Build a Team That Stays

Read article
Cost stacks savings
Hiring Costs

The Best Offshore Staffing Service for Cost Reduction Shows You the Full Cost

For teams preparing for growth, not hype

First step: a 30-minute call with our hiring team to scope the role and quote it.